(original article found here: http://green.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/04/04/who-knew-upcycling-the-dog-poo/?ref=compost&_r=0 )
By Joanna M. Foster
It’s been almost three years since a grand experiment began in Ithaca, N.Y., and the results are finally in. Yet there’s not much to show for it — and that’s what everyone was hoping for.
As Kate Galbraith reported in September 2009, Allan H. Treman Marine State Park in Ithaca generated a lot of buzz by introducing a pioneering waste composting project in its dog park at the urging of a Cornell University professor and other dog owners.
Nationally, some 78 million dogs produce over 10.6 million tons of dung annually. It poses public health risks if left on the streets, is harmful to the environment when left on the side of trails and takes centuries to decompose in plastic garbage bags that end up in landfills.
In the park’s experiment, corn-based compostable bags were placed in dispensers in the dog park. People who visited with their pets were urged to use the bags to retrieve their dogs’ waste and to place them in receptacles. Cayuga Compost, a local company, picked up the waste weekly for processing and composting.
At its composting site in nearby Trumansburg, Cayuga dumped the waste into a pile mixed with a bit of yard and wood waste. In 18 months, the company composted about 12 tons of dog waste from the park that would otherwise have outlived all of the dogs and their owners.
The end result was just two truckloads of compost.
“It’s about a 93 percent consolidation,” said Mark Wittig, program manager at Cayuga Compost.
What is more, lab tests have shown that the compost is pathogen-free — a big concern, given its origins — and has a high-nutrient profile that is perfect for flowers, shrubs and trees, Mr. Wittig said. He called it a great example of upcycling, or taking something that is otherwise considered garbage and turning it into a product with higher value.
When the program began, the idea was to sell the compost, but there’s not enough of it to make such an effort commercially viable. Leon Kochian, a professor of plant biology at Cornell and a member of the Tompkins County Dog Owners Group, said that all of it would probably be returned to the park to help fertilize new trees planted on Earth Day, April 22.
“We might even try and raffle it off as a fund-raiser,” he said. “People love their dogs.”
The park poo project, which costs about $5,000 annually, was financed through donations. Of that, $1,000 goes to Cayuga Compost, and the rest covers the price of 50,000 compostable bags needed to stock the dispensers in the park each year.
Ithaca is not alone in its quest to divert dog waste from landfills. Vancouver, Montreal and Toronto all have similar programs. In the United States, a company in Aurora, Colo., called EnviroWagg collects dog waste from parks, shelters and businesses and sells the finished product, Doggone Good Compost, locally.
Dog waste has also made its way to the big screen, thanks to the Australian filmmaker James Boldiston, who traveled the world — even stopping in Ithaca — for his lighthearted 2011 documentary “Dog Poo: The Truth at Last.”
Although I’m clearly really late with finding this article, I couldn’t pass on posting it up. It’s really uplifting to see that there’s more than a few companies and cities participating in this important issue.
Our pets generate a heck of a lot of waste, and in most cases, a plastic bag gets discarded with each and every dump. Whether it’s a compostable bag or not, the problem is still the problem: organic material hitting the landfill.
I can envision how these cities are getting it done, too. Cleaning up leaves in the fall gives you ample “brown” materials to mix in with the “green” pet waste in a giant compost pile. Temperatures will easily reach thermal kill, and given enough time to sit there and do what the Earth does, it will become soil once again.
Yes, pet waste can be composted. The roadblock for most is just the specifics to create the necessary conditions to render it harmless: a really large compost pile. That’s it.
Since worms and pathogens are a risk to some degree, just create one compost pile that includes all the pet waste, and another pile that doesn’t. Or combine it all into one compost pile and if you’re not comfortable, use the finished product for horticultural purposes.
To save money on bags, try using newspaper, junk mail or pieces of cardboard to scoop up the waste, then drop the whole thing in the compost pile. Although the compostable bags should work and should break down properly, there’s a lot of models out there that don’t compost fully and should be avoided. Did I mention they’re expensive?
No need to get them when you have free materials around that get the job done better. For the cats, if you can get them to use sawdust (not the super fine stuff, although it will mask odor better) in the litter box, you could take care of the waste issue for free. I haven’t tried that for my picky cat yet, but it’s coming.
Anyway, this is a great write-up and I can see this “niche business model” or whatever you’d like to call it taking off quite nicely. Further, if there’s more demand for composting pet waste, that means there must be more attention paid to composting non-pet waste since you need two to tango. Win win!